MENTAL HEALTH

When It Might Be More Than Food

Davin Reed
Rhonda Howard
Lydia Armstrong

Author: Lydia Armstrong, PMHNP

Co-Author: Rhonda Howard, Ph.D.

Editor: Davin Reed

You’ve done the work. Or you’ve tried to. You’ve adjusted what you eat, how often you eat, how you move. You’ve put in the effort — real effort, sustained effort. And something still isn’t adding up the way it should. Maybe the weight has barely moved despite genuinely trying. Maybe the fatigue is heavier than anything your lifestyle seems to explain. Maybe the cravings persist even through good weeks. Maybe your hunger signals are so unreliable you’ve stopped trusting your own body entirely. There’s a version of this conversation that goes: try harder, be more consistent, give it more time. And sometimes that’s true. But there’s another version that doesn’t get said often enough: sometimes the answer isn’t in what you’re eating. It’s in what your labs aren’t showing you. This isn’t about finding an excuse. It’s about getting the full picture — because you cannot solve a problem you can’t see, and some of the most relevant metabolic factors are invisible without specific tests.

Insulin Resistance: The Hidden Driver

Insulin resistance is probably the most common metabolic condition that most people have never been tested for correctly. Here’s how it develops. Over time — through a combination of genetics, chronic elevated blood sugar, excess visceral fat, sedentary behavior, chronic stress, poor sleep, and possibly other factors — your cells begin to lose sensitivity to insulin’s signal. Insulin knocks on the cell door. The cell doesn’t respond as readily. The pancreas compensates by producing more insulin. Blood sugar stays in a normal or near-normal range, because the pancreas is working overtime to maintain it. Everything looks fine on a standard lab panel. But the elevated insulin doing the compensating has its own effects. High circulating insulin is a fat-storage signal. It actively suppresses lipolysis — the process by which your body breaks down stored fat for fuel. It promotes the storage of glucose as fat, particularly visceral fat around the organs. It signals your fat cells to hold rather than release. And it makes the spike-and-crash blood sugar cycle significantly more pronounced. Here’s what matters: you can have insulin resistance with completely normal fasting glucose. A fasting blood sugar of 92 mg/dL looks normal on a lab report. But if your fasting insulin is 25 µIU/mL — which is elevated — your pancreas is working three to four times harder than it should be to produce that normal-looking blood sugar. The resistance is there. The inflammation is happening. The fat-storage environment is active. And a standard diabetes screening missed all of it. The test you need and often don’t get is fasting insulin. Paired with fasting glucose, it allows calculation of HOMA-IR — Homeostatic Model Assessment of Insulin Resistance — which gives a much clearer picture of what your pancreas is actually doing. A HOMA-IR above 1.9 suggests early insulin resistance. Above 2.9 suggests significant resistance. You can calculate it yourself: multiply your fasting glucose (in mmol/L) by your fasting insulin (in µIU/mL) and divide by 22.5.

Prediabetes: The Window Most People Miss

Prediabetes sits in the range between normal blood sugar and a Type 2 diabetes diagnosis. Fasting glucose between 100–125 mg/dL, or an HbA1c between 5.7–6.4%, falls into this category. And it affects a substantial portion of the adult population — many of whom have no idea, because nobody checked, or because a slightly elevated number didn’t trigger a serious conversation. This matters for two reasons. First, prediabetes significantly amplifies everything you’re already experiencing with blood sugar dysregulation — the crashes are harder, the cravings are more intense, the fatigue is more pronounced, and weight management is markedly more difficult. Second, prediabetes is largely reversible at this stage. Lifestyle intervention — the kind of stabilization work this journey is focused on — can bring blood sugar back into normal range. But it requires knowing you’re in that window first. HbA1c (hemoglobin A1c) is the test that catches it. Unlike a fasting glucose snapshot, HbA1c reflects your average blood sugar over the past two to three months. It’s a trend, not a moment. It catches patterns that a single fasting test can miss, especially in people whose glucose is volatile — sometimes normal, sometimes elevated — depending on the day.

Sleep Apnea: The Metabolic Wrecker Nobody Connects to Weight

Sleep apnea is dramatically underdiagnosed, particularly in women, and its metabolic consequences are severe and largely invisible to the person experiencing them. Sleep apnea causes repeated interruptions in breathing during sleep — anywhere from a few to hundreds of times per night. Each interruption activates the sympathetic nervous system: a micro-stress response that raises cortisol and adrenaline. The result is fragmented sleep architecture — your body isn’t getting the deep, restorative stages of sleep where the most critical metabolic repair happens. Chronically disrupted sleep has direct and measurable effects on glucose regulation. Sleep deprivation reduces insulin sensitivity. It raises fasting glucose. It elevates cortisol, which raises blood sugar. It disrupts leptin (your satiety hormone) and elevates ghrelin (your hunger hormone) — producing the combination of increased hunger and reduced fullness signaling that makes every food decision harder. People with untreated sleep apnea often feel like they’re fighting their body’s hunger and energy systems with one hand tied behind their back — because metabolically, they are. And because the cause is happening while they’re unconscious, they typically blame themselves for the symptoms they experience during the day. Signs worth taking seriously: waking unrefreshed even after adequate sleep, loud snoring or gasping noted by a partner, waking with headaches, excessive daytime sleepiness, or a long history of feeling like sleep doesn’t restore you. A sleep study — which can now often be done at home — is the diagnostic tool.

Chronic Stress and the Cortisol Connection

This one is more nuanced, and it needs to be said carefully, because it’s the one most likely to be met with “but everyone has stress.” Cortisol is your primary stress hormone, and its effects on metabolism are direct. Cortisol raises blood sugar — that’s one of its primary functions, because stress was historically physical, and your body needed fuel to respond to it. Cortisol promotes visceral fat storage. It suppresses insulin sensitivity. It disrupts sleep architecture. It elevates appetite and specifically increases craving for high-calorie, high-carbohydrate foods. In someone under acute, temporary stress, this is manageable. The cortisol spike resolves, and metabolic function returns to baseline. But for people under chronic stress — which includes many of the people reading this, because difficult life circumstances, trauma histories, demanding caregiving roles, and financial pressure create sustained cortisol elevation — the metabolic consequences are cumulative and significant. Chronic stress creates a hormonal environment that actively promotes the weight gain and blood sugar instability you’re trying to address. It’s not a willpower problem with stress. It’s that cortisol is doing its job — protecting you from perceived threat — and that job is metabolically expensive. This doesn’t have a simple lab test. But it has a real acknowledgment: if your nervous system is chronically activated, the rest of the metabolic work becomes significantly harder. Stress management isn’t a soft side note to the “real” work. It’s part of the metabolic picture.

The Thyroid: Frequently Missed, Easily Addressed

Hypothyroidism — an underactive thyroid — slows metabolism, promotes weight gain, causes fatigue, disrupts mood, and makes everything about managing weight and energy feel harder than it should. It’s significantly more common in women than men. And it’s frequently underdiagnosed because standard thyroid screening (TSH alone) misses a meaningful percentage of cases. A full thyroid panel includes TSH, free T3, free T4, and sometimes thyroid antibodies to catch autoimmune thyroid disease (Hashimoto’s) before TSH becomes abnormal. If you’ve been told your thyroid is “fine” based on TSH alone, it’s worth asking for the full panel — particularly if you experience persistent fatigue, cold intolerance, hair loss, dry skin, constipation, brain fog, or difficulty losing weight despite genuine effort.

What Labs to Ask For — And How

You don’t need to walk into an appointment with demands. You need to walk in with a clear, honest description of your experience and a specific ask. Fasting glucose and fasting insulin — together, not just glucose alone. Ask explicitly for fasting insulin. It is frequently not included in standard panels. HbA1c — a three-month average of blood sugar that a single fasting test can miss. Full thyroid panel — TSH, free T3, free T4, and if appropriate, thyroid antibodies. Vitamin D (25-OH) — deficiency is linked to insulin resistance, mood dysregulation, and immune function. It’s extremely common and inexpensive to correct. Lipid panel with triglycerides — elevated triglycerides with low HDL is a classic pattern in insulin resistance and metabolic syndrome. Triglycerides above 150 alongside HDL below 40 (in men) or 50 (in women) is worth a conversation. CRP (C-reactive protein) — a marker of systemic inflammation. Low-grade chronic inflammation is associated with insulin resistance and metabolic dysfunction.

No Fear. Just Clarity.

This is not about adding to the weight of what you’re already carrying. It’s about removing the blindfold. If there’s a physiological explanation for why the patterns you’ve been fighting are so resistant — if there’s a reason the standard advice hasn’t worked the way it should have — you deserve to know. Not so you have an excuse to stop trying. So you have actual information to work with. Getting the right labs doesn’t mean something is wrong with you. It means you’re finally taking your own experience seriously enough to investigate it properly. You’ve been working hard, probably for a long time. That effort deserves to be aimed at the right target.

Last Reviewed:
Oct 25th 2025

Rhonda Howard, Ph.D.